Heresy of the special revelation,extended fasting, asceticism and eschatology "The Montanist"

Montanism ([1]Phrygian heresy)
Mentioned in Eusebius, Church History 5.3.4;5.14-18

Historical information

Dating primarily to the late second and early third centuries.
[2]The controversy spread by 177 to Rome.

Leading Teachers

[3]Montanus (170 AD). He was joined shortly thereafter by two prophetesses, Maximilla (2nd century) and Priscilla 92nd century). Tertullian (160-220))

Who contributed in the answering of the heresy

[4]Epiphanius, Panarion 48; Jerome, Letter 41.
[5]Hippolytus Syntagma (lost in its original form; but in substance in later writers),

Characteristic teachings

[6]Montanist prophets claimed direct ecstatic revelations from God to support their teachings on disciplinary questions, especially extended hours of fasting and asceticism, and on eschatology.
[7]It lived in expectation of the speedy outpouring of the holy Spirit (the Paraclete) on the Church, of which it saw the first manifestation in its own prophets and prophetesses.
[8]It was peculiar form of these utterances to which other Christians objected: this kind of ecstatic prophecy was not, like that of the biblical prophets, delivered in the third person, but was direct speech by the Spirit himself using the prophet’s mouth as his instrument. The content of the ‘New Prophecy’ was hostile to the Gnostic elimination of eschatological expectation and insisted on the literal resurrection of the flesh and the nearness of the Lord.     
[9]He (Montanus) began to proclaim to his fellow believers (the New Prophecy) that he was a prophet-that, indeed, he was the mouthpiece of that Spirit which the Lord had promised to the church as the one who would “teach…all things” and  “guide you into all truth.[10]     
[11]The problem was not that Montanus was a prophet, for prophecy had existed in the church since its beginnings, and there is no reason to think that it had died out in the last third of the second century. The problem was that this was a new prophecy. It was unfamiliar in its form(Montanus uttered the words, “Behold a man is as a lyre, and I fly over it like a plectrum,”[12]where the “I” can only refer to the spirit).                              
[13]The Montanist prophets also seem to have practiced “charismatic exegesis,” in which the text of the scripture was actually cited in their oracles in such a way as to include their eschatological key to the scriptures within the text.
One authentic late Montanist inscription substantiates Epiphanius’s charge (Haer.49) that the Montanists allowed female clergy.
In order to survive, Montanists may have developed their own peculiar form of regional bishops to ensure the institutional continuity of the sect.
Became famous after 208 by the joining of Tertullian of Carthage, when he included in Book 4 against Marcion , Montanist passages.
[14]Tertullian also condemned the current penitential disciple for its leniency.
In North Africa , Montanism has long fasts, prohibited second marriages and flight to avoid martyrdom, and specified the exact length of veils to be worn by women.
Montanist prophets also announced an eschatological vision of the heavenly Jerusalem, seen suspended over geographical Jerusalem.
[15]Montanus himself, who began prophesy wither in 172, or 156-7, proclaimed that the heavenly Jerusalem would soon descend near Pepuza in Phrygia.
Spiritual psalms, visions, and prayers also played a part in community life.

Decisions

Were excommunicated in a series of synods of churches in Asia Minor, the first such regional synods in Christian history as (Eusebius, H.E. 5.16.10.
[16]In Rome were excommunicated by bishop Eleutherus
[17]Also condemned by pope Zephyrinus (199-217).

Abbreviation

Encyclopedia of Early Christianity, 2nd edition   (Garland Reference Library of the Humanities)
EEC
Dictionary of the Christian Church edited by F.L. Cross & E.A. livingstone by Hendrickson Publishers. 1997 Oxford university Press.
DCC
A History of the Christian Church, 4th edition Williston Walker and Richard A. Norris, David W. lotz, Robert T. Handy
HCC




[1] After its place of origin and greatest support.
[2] EEC, P.779
[3] EEC, P.778
[4] EEC, p.779
[5] DCC, p.1108
[6] EEC, p.778
[7] DCC, p.1107
[8] EC, P.52
[9] HCC, p.69
[10] John 14:26, 16:13.
[11] HCC, p.69
[12] Stevenson, A New Eusebius, P.113
[13] EEC, P.778
[14] DCC, P.1108
[15] DCC, P.1107
[16] EEC, P. 779
[17] DCC, p.1108

Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

The themes of Sunday Liturgical Readings in the Coptic Orthodox Church

Reading of Sundays Excerpted from many sermons by The V. Rev. Fr. Athanasius K. Farag Sunday reading aims to show us the work of the Holy Trinity in the creation, redemption and glorification  of the human, it is called the economia of the Holy Trinity. Month of Tut In the first month of Tut we read the love of God the Father who called all for repentance “who desires all men to be saved and to come to the knowledge of the truth.” I Ti.2:4 Month of Babah In the second month of Babah, the churches tells us “Who is this Saviour?” we see him through his work miracles of healing the paralyzed, casting out demons, raising the dead. Month of Hatour In Hatour we see who is the Saviour through His word which is planted in our hearts. Month of Keyhak •       All from Luke chapter 1: the scenes which accompanied the Nativity season Month of Toba the incarnation of the Only Begotten Son who called us from darkness to the light, who walked on earth and we saw His gl
Read more

The Biblical Background to the kneeling prayer which is prayed today on the Feast of Pentecost

Explanation of the Kneeling Prayers (“Salaat el Sagda”) on the Feast of the Pentecost by Fr. Bishoy Lamie Mikhail June 8, 2014   Every year on the Feast of the Pentecost, the Coptic Orthodox Church practices “Salaat el Sagda,” or, the “Kneeling Prayer,” in the evening. This important prayer has a deep meaning, as it explains for us the important role of the descent of the Holy Spirit in our salvation and life as a church. “In the Old Testament Pentecost was the feast which occurred fifty days after Passover. As the Passover feast celebrated the exodus of the Israelites from the slavery of Egypt, so Pentecost celebrated God’s gift of the ten commandments to Moses on Mount Sinai. In the new covenant of the Messiah, the Passover event takes on its new meaning as the celebration of Christ’s death and resurrection, the “exodus” of men from this sinful world to the Kingdom of God. And in the New Testament as well, the Pentecostal feast is fulfilled and made new by the coming of the
Read more

Excerpts from St. Cyril of Alexandria commentary on The Book of Jonah

I summarized some points worth mentioning by our great father St. Cyril of Alexandria :  1- The book of Jonah is a "shadow" to the "mystery of the Incarnation of our Saviour". 2- We should not apply the whole story to Jesus, as for example "he was sent to preach to the Ninevites, but tried to flee from the face of God, and proved reluctant about his mission; the Son also was sent by the God and Father to preach to the nations, but did not lack enthusiasm for his ministry, nor seek to flee from the face of the God and Father."  3- the story is meant to be a comparison between how the gentiles accepted the preaching while the Jews rejected it "what happened was by way of condemnation of Israel; they were convicted of being forward, unresponsive, paying little heed to the laws of God.After all, at a single prophet's preaching . the Ninevites were instantly brought around to a sense of obligation to repent, despite suffering from extreme deception
Read more